Josh Johnson or Yovani Galardo?

[PhillyFan89]

What do you guys think?

[dave knight]

I'm not very concerned with Gallardo's ACL (compared with Johnson's elbow), and the Brewer should put up a very, very tantalizing line this year. Go with Gallardo.

[Amazinz]

Gallardo's work load in the 2nd half this season concerns me more than the injury but I'd still take him over Johnson for sure. Johnson does not have the potential that Gallardo does.

[PhillyFan89]

I also have Burnett, Billingsly and Nolasco and I don't think I'd want to drop those guys for Gallardo...

[Guzman24]

Those are 3 very solid options. I guess id drop Nolasco out of the 3 but don't you have another player thats a better option. Id hang on to all of them and pick up gallardo if possible

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=375402

[thatguysound]

Gallardo. He's a better bet to be healthy, and he has more upside. Johnson is top 20-25 at his peak; Gallardo can be top 5-10.