If Smoak is available I'd take him over the pitchers. As much as I like Bumgarner and Hanson, they also has significant flaws that I don't really see in Smoak. Bumgarner's offspeed stuff and Hanson's bb/9 spike are concerning. And if SS is at a premium in your league I would consider Gordon Beckham too.
I'd probably rank them
nevermind my earlier comment about Bumgarner, for whatever reason I thought he was in A+ last year. That was Alderson
Are you interested in joining a 28 teams dynasty league? If so, PM me.