Texeira/Hardy for Reyes/Atkins - PLEASE HELP

[smackarito]

It is a Yahoo 6X6 Roto league - categories are - R's, HR's, RBI's, SB's, AVG and OPS - I was offered this trade, here is my lineup, I am a big Yankee fan, but regardless I am not going to get emotional about trades in a fantasy league, especially with money involved...

C - Posada
1B - Atkins
2B - Uggla
3B - A Ramirez
SS - Reyes
OF - M Ramirez
OF - Rios
OF - Ludwick
UT - Matsui
UT - Hawpe
Bench - Konerko
Bench - B Gardner (now the CF for Yanks, 40-60 SB potential)
Bench - Hafner
Bench - Francoeur

I was offered Mark Texeira and JJ Hardy for Jose Reyes and Garrett Atkins... it hurts my SB's, and I suppose for that matter only helps a little with HR's and RBI's, at least I think... am I better off leaving my team as is or should I accept this offer? HELP PLEASE! Thanks...

[quimmy]

do not make this trade. the drop from reyes to hardy is much greater than the drop in value from texiera to atkins in my opinion. also, if u look to move reyes u have to make sure u get some sb back in the deal or u will regret it. think of reyes like lebron james in fantasy basketball. u need to be overwhelmed to move a stud like reyes and that offer isnt overwhelming.

[Hit Factory]

Hey thanks for help with mine! I would have to agree with the previous poster, The dropoff between Reyes and Hardy is just too big, plus you can get away with having Atkins at first.

[bosoxrock34]

No way Jose... (no pun intended).... That is a pretty one way trade.

some help
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=375495

[Sammy_D]

No way you make that trade, especially not in roto. If it were H2H, you might conider it (even though I still wouldn't so it). But the advantage of having Reyes' steals is worth way too much.

Pass.

[rnatlo]

If you like tex you can think about a possible counter trade since you are given up the best player in the deal you should be getting a quality 2nd player while not giving up much with the second pick...without knowing his roster its tough to suggest who else to target...but remember unless you really love the trade i wouldn't do it since your given up the best player in the deal