Hermida or Headley?

[guyincognito]

Who's going to have the better season? Looking to package one of them in a deal and want to make sure I retain the better option. Just curious of everyone's thoughts. Hermida has never been able to live up to expectations, however, he is having a very nice spring, and Headley is going to be a full time player this year, so with a full season under his belt he could step up and prove why he was one of the top prospects. What do you think?

[barlow078]

When he plays, I believe Hermida will put up better #s. It just depends on how many games he'll be able to play.

[flooredyas]

Depending on your eligibility settings, Headley has 3B/OF positions. While I don't like the SD ballpark for hitters, I would rather have the less injury concern.

[aravtrain21]

Hermida is the guy to go with. He can stay healthy this year and produce good numbers. I would say in 500 ABs he could be among the top 30-40 OF by the end of the season. Keep in mind, he is more of a 2nd half guy.

[dave knight]

The younger Headley is the more tantalizing option.

[roysmalley]

How about throwing Kendry Morales in the mix for the best utility bat?

[The Artful Dodger]

I'd give Hermida another shot. He's been good the last two years when he has played; hopefully, he stays away from the injury bug this year. Improving his home split wouldn't hurt either.