Should I drop Brandon Marrow for Joba Chamberlain?

[BoSoxTown]

Joba just got dropped by one of my team members, should I sign him?

[Crazed98]

If you don't need saves then take Joba

[jtsandwich]

In your 4 team league I guess I would take Joba

[barlow078]

It depends on what the rest of your team looks like.

How many closers do you have? How many closers start in your league? What type of league is it?

Its tough to answer such a question based on so little information.

Overall, in a 12 team yahoo public league....with Joba being only a 5th starter- Morrow is going to be more valuable.

[BoSoxTown]

In your 4 team league I guess I would take Joba

Its a 10 team league


Iannetta, Chris C COL A @ARI @ARI @ARI PHI PHI 95 90 ActiveReserve CU
Youkilis, Kevin 1B BOS A TB TB TB @ANA @ANA 99 97 ActiveReserve 1B3BU
Pedroia, Dustin 2B BOS A TB TB TB @ANA @ANA 99 98 ActiveReserve 2BU
Wright, David 3B NYM A @CIN @CIN @CIN @FLA @FLA 99 99 ActiveReserve 3BU
Peralta, Jhonny SS CLE A @TEX @TEX @TEX TOR TOR 97 91 ActiveReserve SSU
Ellsbury, Jacoby CF BOS A TB TB TB @ANA @ANA 97 90 ActiveReserve OFU
Granderson, Curtis CF DET A @TOR @TOR @TOR @TOR TEX TEX 98 97 ActiveReserve OFU
Lee, Carlos N. LF HOU A CHC CHC CHC @STL @STL 95 91 ActiveReserve OFU
Ortiz, David DH BOS A TB TB TB @ANA @ANA 97 94 ActiveReserve U
Active Pitchers MLB 4/5 4/6 4/7 4/8 4/9 4/10 4/11 Own % Start % Status Pos
Cain, Matt SP SF A MIL MIL MIL @SD @SD 94 78 ActiveReserve SP
Garza, Matt SP TB A @BOS @BOS @BOS @BAL @BAL 93 72 ActiveReserve SP
Matsuzaka, Daisuke SP BOS A TB TB TB @ANA @ANA 96 93 ActiveReserve SP
Pelfrey, Mike SP NYM A @CIN @CIN @CIN @FLA @FLA 87 63 ActiveReserve SP
Capps, Matt RP PIT A @STL @STL @STL @STL @CIN @CIN 70 58 ActiveReserve RP
Gregg, Kevin RP CHC A @HOU @HOU @HOU @MIL @MIL 73 54 ActiveReserve RP
Morrow, Brandon SP SEA A @MIN @MIN @MIN @MIN @OAK @OAK 79 47 ActiveReserve RPSP
Reserve Batters MLB 4/5 4/6 4/7 4/8 4/9 4/10 4/11 Own % Start % Status Pos
Cano, Robinson 2B NYY A @BAL @BAL @BAL @KC @KC 97 92 ActiveReserve 2BU
Cabrera, Orlando SS OAK A @ANA @ANA @ANA @ANA SEA SEA 77 50 ActiveReserve SSU
Bruce, Jay RF CIN A NYM NYM NYM PIT PIT 96 85 ActiveReserve OFU
Pence, Hunter RF HOU A CHC CHC CHC @STL @STL 97 86 ActiveReserve OFU
Reserve Pitchers MLB 4/5 4/6 4/7 4/8 4/9 4/10 4/11 Own % Start % Status Pos
Francisco, Frank RP TEX

thats my current team

[BoSoxTown]

Anyone?

[jetd12]

I would keep Morrow and drop either Cabrera or Francisco for Joba - probably Cabrera.

[KronJon]

Do NOT drop Morrow. He is a closer and a good one at that.

[BoSoxTown]

Ok, I will drop a RP for Joba as I need to drop one cause only 2 are allowed. But who? Frank Francsisco, Matt Capps, Kevin Gregg?

[RowdyRed]

You are only allowed 2 RP, and you have three plus Morrow? This is confusing.

Regardless, I'd drop Francisco of those three for Joba...

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=375658