Undecided on these pitchers...

[hett2333]

In a 12 team mixed, h2h points league, do any of these pitchers upside for 2009 stand above the rest, or are they one of the same?

Trever Cahill, James McDonald, Todd Wellemeyer, Anibal Sanchez, and Koji Uehara...

[Ender]

Depends on your scoring system but in general I like Sanchez the most out of that bunch.

[CadensDad]

I like Sanchez as well over the others

[Yoda]

Man the mods are busy moving these threads around lately. I'd like to see the hamster myself as he's been MIA.

[J35J]

Since these guys are pretty easily replaceable in a 12 teamer I'd go with the guys with the higher upside and give Cahill or McDonald a shot....I'm not a fan of Anibal.

[PlayingWithFire]

Since these guys are pretty easily replaceable in a 12 teamer I'd go with the guys with the higher upside and give Cahill or McDonald a shot....I'm not a fan of Anibal.

ditto, if the league is bigger and I want more consistency I'd probably go with Uehara but he's probably WW level talent in 12 team

[bazzy_51]

given Sanchez chances in the past, and hes had some ups but also some big downs... im actually not as high on the young guys yet like a lot are around the cafe, but give me the choice of Cahill or Sanchez i would take Cahill as his upside imo is much greater then sanchez's... im basing this solely off of the fact that this isn't going to be your #4 or #5 starter, im hoping its more of a bench player to swing in with the best of match ups for either player you select out of this group...

[Element]

I like them in the order in which you have them listed. I actually think Wellemeyer will have a nice season, but I would prefer to go after the high upside or either Cahill or McDonald.

[Matthias]

Man the mods are busy moving these threads around lately. I'd like to see the hamster myself as he's been MIA.

Yah, is Hammie boozing it up in the South Seas?

[WebHamster]

This thread has been eaten by the Webhamster. This typically happens to solitary posts that move too far away from their own kind. Please repost your question or issue in the appropriate forum where it can dwell among the herd of similar threads and where the mods will bravely protect it from the mean rodents. And please ... do not feed the Webhamster! Thank you.