4 Trade offers which one would make my team better WHIR

[jaysfreak91]

Hey I have considered taking offers for Hanley Ramirez and I got 4 offers from people. Out of the 4 I am strongly giving 2 good consideration so which one would make my team stronger

First here's my team
Standard 5X5 H2H
C Mike Napoli
1B Adrian Gonzales
2B Dan Uggla
3B Garret Atkins
SS Hanley Ramirez
OF Jason Bay
OF Ryan Ludwick
OF Jay Bruce
UTL Edwin Encarnacion
B Jason Giambi
B Willy Tavares

SP Jake Peavy
SP Dan Haren
RP Matt Capps
RP Mike Gonzales
P Brandon Morrow
P Gavin Floyd
P Jair Jurrjens
P Oliver Perez
P Todd Wellemeyer
P Jesse Litsch

Here are my trade offers

1. SS Hanley Ramirez
OF Jay Bruce
SP Jesse Litsch

FOR

2B Robinson Cano
OF Matt Holiday
SP Randy Johnson
SP Chris Volstad

+ Improves my OF and kindof improves my pitching
- I don't get a SS in return and have to drop someone, don't need Cano

2. SS Hanley Ramirez
OF Jason Bay
SP Gavin Floyd

FOR

SS Alexei Ramirez(2B,OF)
OF Grady Sizemore
SP Josh Johnson

+ Improves my OF a little I don't take a huge drop in SS and Johnson has great potiential, Ramirez can be OF or 2B as well
- This involes trading my best OF to make the upgrade and Johnson is injury prone

3. SS Hanley Ramirez
OF Ryan Ludwick
SP Todd Wellemeyer

FOR

SS Johnny Peralta
OF Nick Markakis
SP Jon Lester

+ I upgrade OF and SP and don't have to trade Bay to do so.
- might not be full value for Hanley

4. SS Hanley Ramirez
OF Jason Bay
SP Jesse Litsch

FOR

SS Michael Young
C Dionner Navarro
OF Magglio Ordonez
SP Kyle Lohse

+ very little
- I don't need a catcher, I don't really upgrade significantly anywhere I rejected this deal initially instead of Lohse I was offerred Huston Street but I don't need a 4th closer and Street might not be a closer to begin with.

So out of all of these offers I like 2 and 3 the best should I do one or the other or just keep my roster as it is.

Thanks for the help WHIR

[WyldStallyn]

3 and 4 are jokes, 2 is the best but i dont think i'd do it.

[the dresden]

If any of them I'd maybe consider Ramirez, Ludwick, Wellemeyer FOR Peralta, Nick Markakis, Lester

You'd be getting a better SP and Markakis is a nice upgrade over Ludwick, but I don't think that deal's enough for what you're giving up in Hanley. Can you post this guy's roster so we can see what he has to offer, in full?

[jaysfreak91]

Here's the rest of his roster

C Matt Wieters
1B Lance Berkman
2B Jose Lopez
3B Miguel Cabrera
SSJohnny Peralta
OF Carl Crawford
OF Nick Markakis
OF Vladimir Gurerro
UTL Curtis Granderson
B Lastings Milledge

SP Ervin Santana
SP Roy Oswalt
RP Heath Bell
RP Manuel Corpas
P Jon Lester
P Zack Grienke
P Yovani Gallardo
P Scott Baker
P John Danks
P Joey Devine
P Scott Downs

Players in bold are what was offerred to me

And I'll post the entire team from the offer from #2
C Ryan Dourmit
1B Jorge Cantu (3B)
2B Alexei Ramirez(SS,OF)
3B Arimis Ramirez
SS Khalil Greene
OF Grady Sizemore
OF Carlos Quentin
OF Corey Hart
UTL Tori Hunter
B Xavier Nady

SP Ryan Dempster
SP Rich Harden
RP Francisco Cordero
RP Brian Fuentes
P Josh Johnson
P Ubaldo Jiminez
P Anthony Reyes
P Justin Duchscherer
P David Price
P Edwin Jackson
P Trevor Hoffman

[jaysfreak91]

bump

[cranfire87]

If you can get Cabrera instead of Markakis I would consider it, but otherwise I would hold onto Hanley, none of those deals are good enough to deal him for the sake of dealing him