Urgent Advice...Who to drop on my roster?

[Havok1517]

Get rid of Matt Tuiasosopo, Scott Elbert and Melancon

could consider stubbs instead of Elbert.

The thing with Elbert is that he's probably not going back to SP and Melancon is probably not going to be the Yankees closer. Melancon can be a pretty good middle reliever and Elbert has a tiny chance of being a useful SP. Depending on whether you like to gamble or not.

Don't drop Stubbs as he gets Jim Edmonds comparisons with his glove and potential with the bat as he could really breakout this year as he's cutting down on Ks. Elbert has great potential but likely can't stay healthy enough to start full-time and lefty closers are rare. I'd also rather drop Meloan rather than Melancon.

[DevilDriver]

Don't drop Stubbs as he gets Jim Edmonds comparisons with his glove and potential with the bat as he could really breakout this year as he's cutting down on Ks.

He showed very little power last season and had almost as many Ks as games played. Also, most of his numbers came when he was in high A as a 23 yo. Nothing points toward a breakout in AAA. He's a good real-life prospect being a CF with good on-base skills and a great glove, but in fantasy his bat really limits his value.

[Havok1517]

Don't drop Stubbs as he gets Jim Edmonds comparisons with his glove and potential with the bat as he could really breakout this year as he's cutting down on Ks.

He showed very little power last season and had almost as many Ks as games played. Also, most of his numbers came when he was in high A as a 23 yo. Nothing points toward a breakout in AAA. He's a good real-life prospect being a CF with good on-base skills and a great glove, but in fantasy his bat really limits his value.

Compared to prior years he's drastically cut back his k rate which is a promising sign.

[Bigball]

Ive dropped Ike and Tui...

Need to drop 1 more.

looking at Elbert or.......

16 team dynasty h2h... sp,rp,lf,c,rf positions.

I will keep Stubbs

[DevilDriver]

Ive dropped Ike and Tui...

Need to drop 1 more.

looking at Elbert or.......

16 team dynasty h2h... sp,rp,lf,c,rf positions.

I will keep Stubbs

The LF/CF/RF set-up raises Stubbs' value a bit; I'd keep him in that case, too.

I think your last drop should be Meloan.

[DevilDriver]

Don't drop Stubbs as he gets Jim Edmonds comparisons with his glove and potential with the bat as he could really breakout this year as he's cutting down on Ks.

He showed very little power last season and had almost as many Ks as games played. Also, most of his numbers came when he was in high A as a 23 yo. Nothing points toward a breakout in AAA. He's a good real-life prospect being a CF with good on-base skills and a great glove, but in fantasy his bat really limits his value.

Compared to prior years he's drastically cut back his k rate which is a promising sign.

True but he had to sacrifice some power to do so. I'm not convinced he'll be able to increase his power output while sustaining his K-rate progress.

[J35J]

I'd still gladly just get ride of the 3 RP....easy decision for me....it's a rare day when I would keep a minor league RP on any of my fantasy teams.

[DevilDriver]

I'd still gladly just get ride of the 3 RP....easy decision for me....it's a rare day when I would keep a minor league RP on any of my fantasy teams.

Yeah but Ike Davis and Tui?? Both have a next to zero likelihood of becoming top 20 fantasy players at their respective positions. At least the relievers have some upside (to become a closer).

And I'm revising my choice for the last drop again, I didn't realized Elbert was converted to a reliever. Considering Meloan has a much clear path to become closer, I would drop Elbert.

[kab21]

I would drop both Elbert. I would also drop Meloan but you only need to drop one more.

One I wouldn't drop is Wilin Rosario. He's a high risk/reward guy that should be rostered easily in a 320 player MiLB system.