Which team is better??WHIR!!!

[A's_fan]

Ok i wanted to know which team is better, my 1st team or my 2nd team? Both leagues are 12 team, H2H. WHIR!!!, just leave a link

1st team
C-Soto
1b-Delgado
2b-Kinsler
3b-Atkins
SS-Ramirez
OF-Bay
OF-Quentin
OF-Markakis
U-Russell Martin
Bn: O. Cabrera, Griffey, GA, Kelly Johnson, Victorino
SP-Cliff Lee
SP-Liriano
RP-Street
RP-Capps
P-Weaver
P-J. Shields
P-Garza


Heres my 2nd team
C-Napoli
1b-Loney
2b-Kendrick
3b-Kouzmanoff
SS-Hardy
OF-Soriano
OF-BJ Upton
OF-Pence
U-Lowell
Bn: Bartlett, o hudson, glaus, kurt suzuki
SP-Haren
SP-Lackey
RP-Putz
RP-Gregg
P-Harden
P-Juan Cruz
P-Percival

[ragged25]

I like the first team better...Better pitching and a little more talent.

viewtopic.php?f=29&t=375148

Thanks.

[A's_fan]

bump
whir

[taw856]

I like the first team better too, but for me it's in spite of the pitching. Go figure. Not that I think Team 1 has bad pitching, but Cliff Lee could drop off this year and Liriano will still be a minor health concern, while I like Haren/Lackey at the top of Team 2. Still, Hanley, Markakis, Bay, Kinsler, Soto and Martin in the same lineup + deep enough to have Victoriano on the bench grabs the edge for me.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=375158

[Curtis Pride]

Team 1 is significantly better on offense. Way better. The pitching is better in team 2, but it doesn't make up the gap.

viewtopic.php?t=375177

[Chadgo5]

Team one by far. The two teams are closer in pitching than in hitting and team one dominates team 2 in hitting. I'm not in love with either pitching staff though.

viewtopic.php?t=375074