Offered McLouth for Soria & Ian Stewart. WHIR

[BillyHallDisciple]

12-team 6x6 keeper (player values go up $5 per year, there's a $220 salary cap per team). Standard categories + OPS for hitters & k/9 for pitchers.

This guy offered me McLouth for Ian Stewart and Joakim Soria. Should I take it? I kinda like Stewart's upside at my MI slot. If I lose him, I'd have to go with someone like Aaron Hill to fill the spot, and I don't think he has nearly as much upside as I-Stew. I also think McLouth's numbers might go down without Bay in the Pirates' line-up.... also, I love having the Mexicutioner, would hate to give him up.

Thoughts?

12-team, 6x6 Keeper (w/OPS & K/9 added)

C RUSSELL MARTIN, LAD $11
1B PRINCE FIELDER, MIL $25
2B BRANDON PHILLIPS, CIN $17
3B DAVID WRIGHT, NYM $48
SS J.J. HARDY, MIL $11
CI HANK BLALOCK, TEX $1
MI IAN STEWART, CO $1
OF CARLOS LEE, HOU $26
OF JAY BRUCE, CIN $13
OF JACOBY ELLSBURY, BOS $12
OF ANDRE ETHIER, LAD $10
OF PAT BURRELL, TB
UT DANIEL MURPHY, NYM $1
BN MATT WIETERS, BAL $13
BN MATT LAPORTA, CLE $1

SP JUSTIN VERLANDER, DET $6
SP JERED WEAVER, LAA $2
SP UBALDO JIMENEZ, CO $2
SP AARON HARANG, CIN $1
SP JOHN MAINE, NYM $1
RP JOSE VALVERDE, HOU $8
RP JOAKIM SORIA, KC $8
RP CHRIS RAY, BAL $1

[woowoo crew]

i wouldn't do it. you have a solid closer in soria. i'd keep him over mcclouth. your OF looks pretty good as is. watch jordan schafer... you might be able to grab him if you're looking for an outfielder.

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=375073&p=3006911#p3006911

[PavanoAllstars]

i'd hold off on the trade, I was a huge fan of McLovin last year, but i'm not sure he's enough of an upgrade for your of to justify shipping off Stewart and Soria... I think Stewart could pay dividends in your format

hold tight, perhaps see if he'll sweeten the deal with a lower tier closer?

Help me please:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=375113