Shields or King Felix, pick one > WHIR

[dooho]

im thinking about a trade and i need some opinion. my roster is attached in my sig - it's a 12 team 5x5 league.

get: c. jax/king felix or shields
give: youk/heath bell

now i like having 3 solid closers, but i could also use a SP. im also hurting for power and im not sure that giving up youk is the best idea. then again he had a career year last year, does he hit .300 25/110 again, or does he revert back to .285 17/85?

what do you think of this deal and if you like it, which pitcher would you chose?

thanks, leave a link.

[plapre3]

I'd hold off from making the deal. While you can certainly use a pitcher, your offense could use a little help too. I think giving up Youk, one of your best hitters, would be quite the blow. For what it's worth, though, I'd definitely take shields over King-Felix; the win potential makes a huge difference.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=374955&p=3006200#p3006200

[woowoo crew]

i agree with above. i like shields over felix. but, i don't think you need to lose youkilis.

look at mine?? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=375073&p=3006911#p3006911

[dooho]

i hear you guys about youk, but before his huge breakout last year he was a .285 17/85 hitter. guess you're buying into the career year. i also see conor jackson as capable of putting up .300 17 90 himself.

[PavanoAllstars]

I think I lean towards Shields on this one... he's proven himself whereas King Felix has yet to "put it all together"... he's also on an awful awful team...

Please help me:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=375113