What do you guys think? WHIR

[Battaglia]

12 team 5x5 H2H Yahoo standard. Picking tenth of 12.

C-Matt Wieters
1B-Joey Votto
2B-Mark Derosa
3B-Evan Longoria
SS-Jimmy Rollins
OF-Matt Kemp
OF-Brad Hawpe
OF-Curtis Granderson
Util-Chipper Jones
Util-Adrian Beltre

bn-Ramon Hernandez
bn-Denard Span
bn-Kaz Matsui
bn-Adam Laroche
bn-David DeJesus
bn-Micha Hoffpauir

SP-Roy Halladay
SP-Chad Billingsley
RP-Jonathan Broxton
RP-BJ Ryan
P-Matt Cain
P-Chris Carpenter
P-Brandon Morrow
P-George Sherrill
bn-Jair Jurrjens
bn-Matt Thornton

[skjelstrom]

LINEUP- You need a more solid C. I like weiters but i think it will take him a bit to get into the groove and I don't like Hernandez as the backup he hasn't been performing that well. Also I don't like DeRosa. He is very streaky and not always on his best game you need a decent backup for that. I love the rest of your lineup though as long as Chipper stays healthy.

Rotation - You have GREAT pitchers IF Morrow stays in the starting lineup (which it is possible he could go back to bullpen....) and if Carpenter can stay healthy and stay in the lineup. If those 2 stay you will have a GREAT pitching staff. You do need a backup RP though. Im not sold on Broxton yet and you don't have a backup so keep your eye out for that. But with BJ Ryan now with the job, as long as he keeps it your good.

Overall good draft. But keep an eye out for RP and a high upside C.

Can you help with mine please? viewtopic.php?t=374432

[Battaglia]

Well i like Hernandez simply because of the park he plays in. 20 HR potential is there in my opinion. Of course he's simply a stop gap for Wieters once hes up to speed. I agree on DeRosa, he was a very late round pick because I had passed on other second baseman for guys i thought had good value(like Chipper). I will most likely try trading one of my thirdman for a second baseman. Thanks for the input.