Pick me a pitcher!

[MasterX1918]

20 team 5x5 Roto redraft league. I currently have Sean Gallagher on my squadron but i'm thinking about replacing him with one of these pitchers. Pick my bride.

Sean Gallagher
Andrew Miller
Glen Perkins
Nick Blackburn
Doug Davis
James McDonald
Ricky Romero
Brett Anderson
Franklin Morales
Rick Porcello
Dave Bush
Anibal Sanchez
Koji Uehara
Kyle Davies
Daniel Cabrera

[ayebatter]

Dave Bush, 'nuff said.

[MasterX1918]

I hope hoping for someone with a little more upside

[ayebatter]

I hope hoping for someone with a little more upside

So you want upside or a usable piece. Bush

[HOOTIE]

McDonald is the 5th sp. Porcello could win the 5th spot.

[MadDog36]

You want a player with some upside and given no fantasy relevance at all? Kyle Davies, he's not even the 5th starter (4th). He had a great September and word is he's looking good. Anibal is due for a bounceback season. I would also look possibly at Morales and his huge upside. But problem is having #5 starters. Its hard to count on them consistantly for starts.

Blackburn is IMO the safest option on this list (think Brad Radke). he's great especially for home starts. Plus, he's not the 5th starter and will be starting games regularly for your team if need be.

Brett Anderson
Franklin Morales
Rick Porcello

I assume this isn't a keeper with these guys as FAs? Please answer this question (post your complete roster along with other FAs).

Personally I'd want to see your roster before i give you any more advice.

[MasterX1918]

I already said it's a 20 team roto redraft league, so no keepers.

C-Joe Mauer
1B-Prince!
2B-Polanco
3B-Chase the Ace Headley
SS-O-Cab
OF-CBeltran
OF-Dukes
OF-DeJesus
UTIL-Carlos Pena
BN-Carlos Gomez
BN-Asdrubal Cabrera
BN-Jordan Schafer (I picked him up on a whim today when the Braves traded Anderson/dropped Andy LaRoche)

SP-Danny Haren
SP-Ricky Nolasco
RP-Brad Lidge
RP-Francisco Cordero
P-Kenshin Kawakami
P-Ryan Madsen
P-Jeremy Bonderman
BN-Max Scherzer
BN-Sean Gallagher

Joe Blanton, Looper, Marquis, Greg Smith are also available. I really did post the only appealing FA starters.

[MasterX1918]

any other input?