C.Lee /Aviles for Atkins/Carpenter?

[guyincognito]

Trying to work on a deal with an owner interested in Aviles. Was thinking of offering Cliff Lee and Aviles for Atkins and C.Carpenter. Would you do it? (roster and league info below)

---------------------------------------------------
14 team, H2H, Keeper League (keep 2)
B Cats: Avg, E, H, HR, PP, R, RBI, SB
P Cats: W, L, K, QS, ERA, WHIP, HD, S

C - V.Martinez
1B - M.Teixeira
2B - M.Aviles
SS - D.Jeter
3B - E.Longoria
OF - Ichiro, T.Hunter, J.Hermida
DH - Konerko
U - Sheffield
Bench - DeJesus, Headley, Byrnes, B.Wood
SP - A.J.Burnett, C.Lee, E.Santana, B.Myers
RP - M.Rivera, M.Gonzalez, H.Street, O.Dotel, R.Soriano
Bench - O.Perez, M.Parra, M.Guerrier

[lastingsgriller]

why would you do this? you already have a solid 1B and 3B so atkins is worthless to you and you don't have anyone to fill Aviles' position...

[guyincognito]

I was originally going to make a play for Burrell since I felt I needed some help in the OF. Then in some discussion with the owner he mentioned that Atkins was available too. Atkins is a better player then Burrell and would provide me with some depth and add a better Util option then Sheffield. Plus Atkins with his dual eligability, will be easier for me to move, better trade bait. We've been tossing a few thing around and I was thinking of this since I'm not very high on Lee and have liked what I have been seeing from Carpenter so far, so I figured it might be a trade off Lee/Carpenter, so then it's Aviles for Atkins, which would be a good deal for me, because I can then turn Atkins around if needed for a better 2B or OF. But it sounds like Lee is not the guy to part with in this deal.