David Ortiz for Papelbon

[Tarquin]

I get: David Ortiz
I give: Papelbon

Do it or not? Also while we are at it, should I drop Kaz Matsui for Cameron Maybin? I was also offered J.J Putz for Brandon Morrow. Morrow is in the bullpen now (Probably closing) but Putz should be the best holds guy in MLB this season.

Team: 10 team H2H with standard 5X5 plus OPS Hits Holds K/9 .

C - Mike Napoli
1B - Carlos Delgado
2B - Robinson Cano
3B - David Wright
SS - Michael Young
OF - Matt Holliday
OF - Carlos Lee
OF - Jacoby Ellsbury
Util - Mark Derosa
Util - Torri Hunter
Bench - Kazuo Matsui

SP - Johan Santana
SP - Roy Halladay
RP - Jonathon Papelbon
RP - Joe Nathan
RP - Joakim Soria
P - Scott Kazmir
P - Brandon Morrow
P - Rafael Soriano
Bench - Rafael Perez
Bench - Aaron Harang
Bench - Chad Qualls
Bench - Juan Cruz
Bench - Matt Lindstrom
Bench - Oliver Perez

[Amazinz]

I would take Putz over Morrow (unless it's a keeper) and Maybin over K. Matsui. As for Ortiz, it depends on what you expect out of him. I'm personally bullish and would probably do it because Ortiz can be quite a bit more valuable than Paps in this setup, I favor hitting in H2H when it's close, and you have the SV to spare.

[MMBosstones86]

putz over morrow
maybin over matsui
you miiiight be able to get more for papalebon, since he is a top level closer and ortiz is basically a question mark. You could try shopping around more and if nothing else pops up, go for it