Good Trade? Prince + for Kinsler + WHIR

[doubleplay122000]

Team A: Prince, Hudson, Atkins
for
Team B: Votto, Kinsler, Bell

which side wins on value? which side wins overall (rosters below)? 12 team 5x5 H2H

Team A
C- Sandoval
1b - Prince
2b - Hudson
3b - C. Davis
SS - Hanley
OF - Markakis, Kemp, BJ
Util - Ibanez
BN - Atkins, F. Lopez, J. Bruce, Wieters
SP - J. Vazquez, U. Jimenez, Wainwright, Carpenter, Greinke, J. Johnson
RP - Gregg, Ray, Arredondo, Ziegler

Team B
C- Martin
1b - Votto
2b - Kinsler
3b - Zimmerman
SS - Tejada
OF - Sizemore, Beltran, Crawford
Util - Ortiz
BN - Ankiel
SP - Baker, Harang, J. Weaver, E. Santana, Morrow, Parra, J. Sanchez, J. Zimmerman, B. Anderson
RP - Jenks, Valverde, Capps, Bell

WHIR if you leave a link

[Amazinz]

Pretty close trade based on how the consensus is valuing them. My personal opion is that the Fielder side of the deal wins by quite a bit in the long run.

[oldschool5]

prince, hudson and atkins hands down...

[fierro33]

it is not hands down but the prince side wins in a close one........overall

[4Pack]

I agree that it is fairly close and I also would probably take the Fielder side (but that may be the Brewer fan in me talking)

[doubleplay122000]

thanks for the replies everyone
so I am team A (the current Prince owner) and was thinking of offering this trade...seeing the opinions of the other cafers, i'm wondering how i can tweak this deal a bit to make it better for me

i realize in the current trade, im downgrading at 1B (though i really like votto this season) but feel the upgrade at 2B is huge, and atkins is nothing more than a trade chip for me...im punting saves, but bell would then become someone i could move to another team, or keep to help with ratios, and at least force people to be honest when i play them