Trade Chipper/C Guillen for Atkins??

[scorer8989]

Custom redraft league (R,HR,RBI,SB,E,AVG,W,SV,K,ERA,WHIP). I'm worried about Chipper's health, should I trade him and Carlos Guillen for Garret Atkins? Thanks in advance...

my team

c: Shoppach
1b: Tex
2b: Roberts
3b: C Jones
ss: Lowrie
mi: F Lopez
of: Braun, Quentin, Granderson, Abreu
ut: Adrian Gonzalez

sp: F Hernandez, C Zambrano
rp: Ryan, Bell
p: Cain, Carpenter, B Wilson, Balfour

bench: Kuroda, Pelfrey, C Guillen, B Butler, F Lewis

[Amazinz]

I wouldn't. Even with 425 AB or so, Jones should put up comparable numbers to Atkins. And if he manages to post more, he'll out-produce him.