Huff vs. Atkins in 2009?

[Ballpark Frank]

Which 1B/3B option do you think will be the most productive in 2009: Aubrey Huff or Garrett Atkins? Both should bat cleanup in explosive offenses, yet I'm having trouble convincing myself to like either one. Who has the best 2009..Huff or Atkins?

[Amazinz]

Atkins should be slightly better across the board except in power. They're fairly close but Atkins will be more valuable overall IMO.

[Ballpark Frank]

Thanks for the feedback. I wish somebody could somehow convince me to like one of these guys!