Davis/Votto for Billingsley, etc. (WHIR)

[dave knight]

I'm thinking of trading a first baseman, either Chris Davis or Joey Votto, for an elite pitcher in Billingsley. I know I can sweeten the pot a little bit, but how? I'm going to need a replacement infielder, Maybe Mark Ellis? Or be more ambitious and ask for a better catcher in Doumit or Napoli? Or would you just not do any deal and stay pat with the pitching I have?

1 year league. Roto categories:

R, H, HR, RBI, SB, BB, TB, AVG, SLG
IP, W, CG, SHO, SV, K, HLD, ERA, WHIP

My team:
C - Iannetta, Clement
1B - Berkman, Davis
2B - Roberts, Weeks
3B - Wright, C. Jones
SS - Drew, Andrus
IF - Votto
LF - Manny
CF - McLouth
RF - Dukes
OF - Lewis, Ross, Drew
Util - Snider
BN - John Baker

SP - Nolasco, Harden, Lowe, Greinke, Randy Johnson, Jimenez, J. Sanchez
RP - Cordero, Bell, Putz, Balfour

Other team:

C - Doumit, B. Molina
1B - Loney, LaRoche
2B - Ellis, A. Hill
3B - LaRoche, Fields
SS - Alexei, Rollins
IF - Headley
LF - C. Lee
CF - Sizemore
RF - Markakis
OF - Ludwick, Chris Young, Adam Jones
Util - M. Napoli

SP - Peavy, Billingsley, Vazquez, Meche, Volquez, Cueto, Jurrjens, Kawakami
RP - Broxton, B. Wilson, Hanrahan, Juan Cruz

[Trojan Pony]

Maybe try Davis for Billingsley/LaRoche? That seems reasonable to me, and I think an ace like Billingsley would help your team enough to take the downgrade at IF.

[dave knight]

Maybe try Davis for Billingsley/LaRoche? That seems reasonable to me, and I think an ace like Billingsley would help your team enough to take the downgrade at IF.

Which LaRoche?

[Trojan Pony]

Oh, haha, didn't realize he had both... I meant Adam (1B).

[Crazed98]

What about Chipper he seems to be just wasting space on your team