Ichiro for Roberts (WHIR)

[dartagnan59]

Take this trade?

My team:
C Brian McCann
1B Adam Dunn
2B Brian Roberts
3B Edwin Encarnación
SS Jimmy Rollins
OF Ryan Braun
OF Josh Hamilton
OF Vernon Wells
Util Stephen Drew
SP CC Sabathia
SP Brandon Webb
RP Mike González
RP Bobby Jenks
P Huston Street
P Yovani Gallardo
P Chris Young
BN Brad Hawpe
BN Conor Jackson
BN José López
BN Jorge Posada
BN Johnny Cueto

His team:

C Ryan Doumit
1B Albert Pujols
2B Felipe Lopez
3B Aramis Ramírez
SS Jose Reyes
OF Alfonso Soriano
OF Ichiro Suzuki
OF Magglio Ordóñez
Util Jermaine Dye
SP Jake Peavy
SP Dan Haren
RP Carlos Mármol
RP Francisco Cordero
P Scott Baker
P Chris Carpenter
P John Danks
BN Joey Votto
BN Pablo Sandoval
BN Felipe López
BN Brad Ziegler
BN Trevor Hoffman

[woowoo crew]

w/out knowing your line-up, i'll just say this:

if you're getting roberts, i'd do it. if you're giving up roberts, i wouldn't. roberts has more power potential, and is just as likely to steal 30 plus bases as ichiro.

help me out please: Currently, I'm not feeling well... I've been drinking Alka-Seltzer all night... yuck. Hopefully, I'll feel better tomorrow, but if not, I probably won't make it. Just wanted someone to know.

[tribefan08]

Bip roberts? no way LOL

brain? ok i guess... kinda like switching apples for apples except one apple plays OF and one plays 2B....

just depends which end you're on and what you need....

personally i'd rather have ichiro than roberts, but its pretty much a coin flip.... in a draft i'd take NEITHER

[dartagnan59]

Lineup added.

[flloyd]

I'd rather have Roberts. Similar production at a weaker position.

[Surfs up]

Roberts for me too.

[Grounded Polo]

Stick with Roberts, already having two first round outfielders doesn't sway this one in Ichiro's favor, given that their production is basically equal.