Jay Bruce for Jason Bay?

[HustlinOwl]

He wants to trade Jay Bruce for Jason Bay, what do you guys think?


My Team

Bengie Molina (C)
Ramon Hernandez (C)
Joey Votto (1B)
Jose Lopez (2B)
Hanley Ramirez (SS)
Edwin Encarnacion (3B)
Travis Ishikawa (1B)
Eugenio Velez (2B)
Carlos Quentin (OF)
Ryan Ludwick (OF)
Jason Bay (OF)
Jack Cust (OF, DH)
Fred Lewis (OF)
Chone Figgins (3B/UTL)

Daisuke Matsuzaka (SP)
Aaron Harang (SP)
Armando Galarraga (SP)
Edwin Jackson (SP)
Joe Nathan (RP)
Jonathan Papelbon (RP)
Joakim Soria (RP)
Justin Duchscherer (SP)
Takashi Saito (RP)

BENCH
Ian Stewart (3B)
Jed Lowrie (SS, 3B)
Chris Dickerson (OF)
Koji Uehara (SP)
Michael Bourn (OF)
Brett Gardner (OF)


Minors
Trevor Cahill
Brett Wallace
Todd Frazier
Dayan Viciedo
Nick Adenhart
Lou Marson
Ramon Ramirez
Drew Stubbs
Brian Bogusevic
Kellen Kulbacki

[joe112]

No

[HustlinOwl]

That would be way too many Reds players on my team LOL

[TheNephilim]

No there is a 2-3 round discrepancy between the two players in a non keeper league.

[money]

I would keep Bay.

[Amazinz]

Keep Bay.

[yanks0826]

No way you trade Bay for Bruce.

[DaShiz23]

Keep Bay.

For you to consider this, he would have to add a mid-tier SP.

[4Pack]

I also go with the keep Bay consensus.

[Johnny Tuttle]

Folks, are we so sure this is a redraft? They've got minor leaguers and everything. In a keeper, I absolutely do this, and then I dance for joy. I own Bruce in a keeper and I wouldn't trade him last year for Guerrero or this for Manny.

In a redraft, I ask for something else and still do it. If you could upgrade Ishikawa to something tastier, that's the incentive.