BJ Upton for Nate Mclouth

[MrNerd93]

Is BJ going to come back from last year or is this a good trade?

[Jond4414]

Upton will be fine. Id hold on to him. His upside alone makes him a better bet this season than Mclouth.

[smoovethug]

You aren't getting enough in return here. Upton will out-steal Nate and if the power returns as it should you're looking at a 20/40 type season from BJ.

[woowoo crew]

i like power, and to me, mclouth has more potential for power than upton. i would wait and see how they do, then make the deal... if you can afford to wait. right now, the name alone with upton is worth more than mclouth, so you could get more.

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=374292

[RRGL1]

I would much rather have Upton; not really even close for me.

[MrNerd93]

I was already siding with Upton in the first place and you all just confirmed it. Thanks

[V]

Upton without a doubt, and I'm a huge McLouth fan.