My Upton for his Utley straight up

[melloyello]

He needs a CF and I need a 2b. I think i get the better half of this deal but it doesn't seem too far off. Make the trade?

My team is in sig. My other option was my Granderson & Kaz for Utley, but he might not take that.

[KronJon]

I'd rather have Utley in either of those trade situations. A lot of sites rank Upton higher than Utley but I disagree with that. Utley will produce as a first rounder and you need an upgrade at 2B.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=374245

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd rather have Utley but Upton might be able to get it done.

[REBEL5 AC]

Keeper league - DON'T DO IT!!!! Upton will be the real deal.

Single year league - Do it, Utley will have much better numbers than Upton