Rank these Catchers

[the izzy]

Catchers went early. Waited on Weiters, but he went in the 11th rd - I had him pegged for a 12-13th rd selection.

Anyway, 10 team keeper league, H2H 7x7 w/ OPS and H as the extra categories.

I currently own Shoppach because of his large OPS. Should I drop him for another C?

D. Navarro
AJ Pierzynski
J. Clement
J. Saltalamacchia
C. Snyder
Teagarden
K. Suzuki

Teagarden had the best OPS and AVG last year, but will that continue and will he get enough AB's?
Navarro is coming off a great year last year. Should I grab him, or roll the dice on the 20+ HR Shoppach?

my team:
C: Shoppach
1B: Pujols
2B: B. Roberts
3B: A. Ramirez
SS: T. Tulo
OF: A. Soriano
OF: M. Ordonez
OF: J. Bruce
UTIL: Prince Fielder (1B)
BN: J. Upton (OF), C. Maybin (OF)

Pitching:
Liriano, AJ Burnett, Gallardo, Wang, Scherzer, Price, Kershaw, Maine, Carmona, Bedard
Hoffman, Mike Gonzalez.

[Padres Fan]

Shoppach isnt guaranteed starter time,

AJ you know what you get

my sleeper pick is Kurt Suzuki, batted .279 7 hrs in 500+ at bats, looks to go .280 15 hrs this season plus he has noone behind him to take away playing time, Landon Powell(?), Navarro is the only one who will get for sure starting time as well but hits a boring .260 7 hrs

[epp1e]

AJ's HRs have been going down steadily year after year. I like Kurt Suzuki as well, and (people will probably call me crazy for this one) I'm betting Jesus Flores is available in your league & I like him as a sleeper as well.

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

Suzuki
AJ
Salty
Navarro

Flores is interesting, i'm just not willing to commit to him yet


please help
viewtopic.php?t=374151

[HOOTIE]

Shoppach. VMart is going to play 1B a lot.

[the izzy]

Thanks for all the replies guys. It seems that I have a vote for AJ, vote for Shopp and a vote for Suzuki.

Never heard of Jesus Flores, and yes he's available. His #'s don't seem impressive though, what's the projection here? Low avg, low # of SB, low ops and low HR total.

Any other opinions. Thanks.

[fierro33]

out of all those i still like shoppach in a close call over suzuki.........AJ can suck it

maybe shoppach can put up napoli type numbers


viewtopic.php?f=29&t=374162

[Padres Fan]

But you got Shoppach/V Mart/Garko and Hafner, not to mention LaPorta when he gets called up, all fighting with the C/1B/DH spots so I just don'r see Shppach craking 400 At Bats, Flores is intriguing but numbers aren't there yet. I still think Suzuki will be the sleeper pick

[the izzy]

Ramón Hernández was just dropped in this league, do any of you expect a good season from him? I've heard a lot of people are pretty high on a bounce back season for him.

[Padres Fan]

he wil givse some pop about 15hrs in about 450 at bats and hit abou .250-.260, I still stand by my Kurt Suzuki, with no real back up he could plate 500+ at bats again, like last season, plus hit .280 15 hrs he did hit .279 7 hrs in first full season.