2 trade options, trying to decide today

[dubstar]

10 team h2h keeper: avg., hr, rbi, r, sb, xbh
era, w, sv, k, whip, qs

C Sandoval
1B Fielder
2B Aviles
3B Wright
SS Drew
OF Manny, Kemp, Bruce
UTIL Dunn
BN Wieters, Maybin, C Pena

SP Webb, Shields, Gallardo, Grienke, Dempster, Harang, Kershaw

RP Wood, Bell

option 1: give fielder/aviles, i get kinsler

option 2: i give dunn/dempster/aviles, i get uggla/billingsley

the first one seems fair to me. i was just not wanting dunn and pena's crappy average on the same team. but kinsler might be worth it. fielder will probably have a huge power year, but can i afford to lose it?

the second one has been laid out with a friend, but ive become worried with billingsley's injury. he isnt starting saturday, im just worried that this could linger and affect him all year. also i wouldnt be able to make this trade until closer to the season, since my friend needs to place someone on the DL to accept the extra player.

[FantasySportsMaven]

No to option 1
Yes to option 2

Help me too? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=374067

[dubstar]

No to option 1
Yes to option 2

Help me too? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=374067

what are your reason?

[dubstar]

bump, anyone else? im having a tough time deciding

[fan of the cubs]

I wouldn't do the first one. I would do the 2nd one, although I didn't know Billingsley was hurt. Dunn is hot garbage and I don't see Dempster doing the same he did last year (this coming from a cubs fan who watches every game).

[dubstar]

whats the reasoning behind not doing the first one?