reyes for kinsler and jeter??

[aleo824]

Should i pull the trigger on trading Reyes for Kinsler and jeter

[trevizzle]

with jeter moving up in the lineup... i do it.

but i need to see your lineup

[TheBull]

Both Kinsler and Reyes are 1st RD picks playing at scare positions.. I take Kinsler/Jeter fairly easily

[aleo824]

okay he pulled the trade cause im a pussy who needs to go on forums before making decesions but countered with roy oswalt and jeter for reyes. my lineup reads like so (h2h keepers):

C Brian McCann, Atl C
1B Carlos Pena, TB 1B
2B Kelly Johnson, Atl 2B
3B Kevin Youkilis, Bos 1B, 3B DTD
SS Jose Reyes, NYM SS
IF Adam LaRoche, Pit 1B
OF Alfonso Soriano, ChC OF
OF Bobby Abreu, LAA OF
OF Hunter Pence, Hou OF DTD
OF Ryan Ludwick, StL OF
UTIL Rick Ankiel, StL OF
Bench Hideki Matsui, NYY OF, DH
Bench Rickie Weeks, Mil 2B

P David Price, TB SP
P Frank Francisco, Tex RP
SP CC Sabathia, NYY SP
SP James Shields, TB SP
SP Adam Wainwright, StL SP
SP Kevin Slowey, Min SP
RP Jose Valverde, Hou RP
RP Brian Fuentes, LAA RP
Bench Fausto Carmona, Cle SP
Bench Brandon Lyon, Det RP

[Dislexic Irishman]

Definitely no to that second trade. I wouldn't do the first either as I don't expect a whole lot from Jeter, but it is close enough to consider. Plus, KJ is solid (same HR/SB/R/RBI numbers as Jeter last year) and Rickie Weeks does have breakout potential

EDIT to show how crazy similar Kelly Johnson was to Jeter last year.. Jeter's stats first

GP R HR RBI BB SB CS
150 88 11 69 52 11 5
150 86 12 69 52 11 6

Jeter had 22 more hits while KJ had 14 more doubles and 3 more triples
Granted, Jeter could hit 20 or even 30 points higher in BA but I still don't like the trade

[C2ThaLo88]

Definitely no to that second trade. I wouldn't do the first either as I don't expect a whole lot from Jeter, but it is close enough to consider. Plus, KJ is solid (same HR/SB/R/RBI numbers as Jeter last year) and Rickie Weeks does have breakout potential

[philaphan]

I would think about the 1st one but since he pulled it....the 2nd offer is a joke!


Please help me
viewtopic.php?t=374081

[epp1e]

The 2nd offer was such a joke that I actually had Diet Coke come out of my nostrils.

K, not really, but it's still a joke.

[TheNephilim]

The 2nd offer was such a joke that I actually had Diet Coke come out of my nostrils.

K, not really, but it's still a joke.

Made me laugh, agree don't do it

[WyldStallyn]

2nd is absurd. i wouldve passed on that first deal