J.J. Hardy for Billy Butler? WHIR

[aravtrain21]

I think this trade would make my team better in HR and AVG. His SS is Bentancourt and he could use the upgrade. What do you think? Leave a link and I promise WHIR! Here's some background...

14 Team H2H league.
Offensive Categories: 1B, RBI, R=1, 2B=2, 3B=3, HR=4, BB=.5, HBP=.5, K=-.5, SB=2, CS=-1.
Pitching Categories: INN=1, K=1, BB=-.5, HB=-.5, ER=-1, W,S,SHO,CG=10, L,BS=-5.
Active Batters
Molina, Bengie C SF
Votto, Joey 1B CIN
Cano, Robinson 2B NYY
Furcal, Rafael SS LA
Wright, David 3B NYM
Crawford, Carl LF TB
Kemp, Matt OF LA
Quentin, Carlos LF CHW
Pence, Hunter RF HOU (U)
Active Pitchers
Lincecum, Tim SP SF
Billingsley, Chad SP LA
Nolasco, Ricky SP FLA
Garza, Matt SP TB
Slowey, Kevin SP MIN
Jenks, Bobby RP CHW
Gregg, Kevin RP CHC
Reserve Batters
Posada, Jorge C NYY
Hardy, J.J. SS MIL
Fields, Josh 3B CHW
Nady, Xavier RF NYY
Jones, Adam CF BAL
Spilborghs, Ryan RF COL
Reserve Pitchers
Cueto, Johnny SP CIN
Kawakami, Kenshin SP ATL
Motte, Jason RP STL

[wyld stallions]

I would not do this. I think JJ will have a good year this year. Plus with Furcal as your SS you should have a backup just incase he gets inj. Butler is a good player but has not done anything yet.

[Amazinz]

I don't see anything wrong with trading Hardy but I think you would be underselling him for Butler.

[cnote23]

No don't do it JJ hardy is a better player you could get much more for him.

[mak1277]

yep, get more for JJ.

[FantasySportsMaven]

Agree with others, Hardy is worth more than Butler. Who else is on his roster?

Help me too? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=374029&p=2999864#p2999864

[aravtrain21]

Suggestions on who would be better than Butler? Here are some players he might be interested in trading...

Butler, Kotchman, Casey Blake, Burrell, Dye, Griffey. I think Butler is the best out of all those guys except maybe Dye.

[TheNephilim]

Suggestions on who would be better than Butler? Here are some players he might be interested in trading...

Butler, Kotchman, Casey Blake, Burrell, Dye, Griffey. I think Butler is the best out of all those guys except maybe Dye.

Hardy is a 2nd tier quality SS, you should def. get more than Butler. Burrell or Dye might be a little closer.

[rnYanksNinersKnicks]

I gota go with the majority here and say don't do it...Butler has done little in almost every oppurtunity that he has had and they gave him plenty

[soty]

Same as others you can get more for Hardy.