Jose Guillen or Dan Murphy (Mets)

[evilempire2]

who do you guys think will have the better season? Guillen is on my team now, but is not in my starting OF. I'm considering dropping Jose for Murph in hopes of getting a solid young talent with high potential.

Guillen is still an everyday player and Murphy may be platooning in the OF. I just would like another opinion on whether or not i should make this move.

Thanks guys.

leave a link ill do yours

[RRGL1]

Well, it is a bench spot so it is not as critical. Depending on the rest of my team, I may do different things. Guillen is the better safe pick but Murphy hitting 2nd in the lineup is interesting. I might make my decision based on which categories I need more, HR/RBI, or R/Avg.

[America'sGame]

Well, it is a bench spot so it is not as critical. Depending on the rest of my team, I may do different things. Guillen is the better safe pick but Murphy hitting 2nd in the lineup is interesting. I might make my decision based on which categories I need more, HR/RBI, or R/Avg.

I agree with the analysis here, but I'd still go with Murph here since we're not talking about a starter. Murph has potential and could be decent trade bait as the season goes on. And if not, it only cost you Jose Guillen and not a guy like Delmon Young or better.

pls see mine
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=373978&p=2999551#p2999551