Posada/Putz or Posada/Scherzer for Wieters? WHIR

[FantasySportsMaven]

Should I offer this deal?

12 team H2H Yahoo Redraft league with 5x5 scoring.
Start: C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF, OF, OF, UT, SP, SP, RP, RP, P, P, P

Here is my current roster:
C: VMart, Posada
1B: Dunn, Atkins
2B: Utley, Matsui
SS: Peralta
3B: Atkins, Wiggington
OF: Braun, Pence, Lind, Dan Murphy, Wiggington
UT: Ortiz
SP: Lester, Lilly, Je Weaver, Maholm, J Zimmerman, Duchscherer, Scherzer
RP: Valverde, Hanrahan, Corpas, Putz, Scherzer

The other owner's only other catcher is Snyder. He has already offered me Wieters/Schumaker for VMart but I turned it down.

Should I offer this deal and see what happens? He already turned down my offer of Posada/Pierre for Wieters/Schumaker.

Leave a link and I'll help you too.

[lmearstx]

I'd go with the Posada/Putz offer. Scherzer is a risk, but his arm is lightning. And Putz isn't going to sniff more than 3-4 saves this season setting up K-Rod.

[FantasySportsMaven]

Offered Posada/Putz.

If rejected, should I offer Posada/Duchscherer for Wieters/Schumaker?

[Barnes]

Posada and Putz for sure. Scherzer is a risk but he has so much upside its worth it. Putz will be a solid set-up man for K-rod, but will only get a few saves.

[lmearstx]

No, I'd hold onto Duchscherer. Your staff is not that deep. Honestly, I'd go with Corpas as my backup offer. Street seems to be leading that closer race in Colorado

Help with my trade dilemma? viewtopic.php?t=373947

[Zhangman1]

i'd see what he counters with. i'd give up corpas or putz before SPs esp. Scherzer

[FantasySportsMaven]

He accepted the offer of Posada/Putz for Wieters. Gulp. Hope I didn't make a mistake?

Thanks to everyone for the help.

End of this thread.