Fair enough, Hybrid. This is my first Fantasy Cafe post, so I am still learning the ropes, and I apologize. I'd even delete the post, but don't know how.
My intention was to guage which players other keeper leaguers would deem the most valuable if they had the same specific pool of players to choose from. (BTW, I have my own ranking prepared, but was just curious what other die hards think. I just didn't want to share my thoughts until others weighed in). I thought that other keeper leaguers might have similar pools for their draft, since many teams would not own Ricky Nolasco (breakout) or Josh Johnson (injury) or similar players.
My league is very unique -- a homemade league, basically -- but is probably most comparable to a 12 team, 5x5, keeper league. I will be in contention this year, so I am mostly thinking about TRADE VALUE. Who will be the most valuable trade chips come August? But of course, if I can pick up a player that can actually help me contend in 2009, I will do that.