Big new trade offer....WHIR

[casem2k2]

In a 10 team 5x5 roto league

Do I trade Bay,Ortiz,Dice k for Morneau,Ordonez,Wainwright???

My lineup:
c pierzynski
c olivo (until wieters is called up)
1b fielder
2b derosa
3b c.jones
ss hanley
ci delgado
mi k.johnson
of beltran
of bay
of hart
of milledge
util ortiz
util c.young
b kouzmanoff, jacobs, wieters, carlos gomez

sp j.santana
sp d.haren
sp dice-k
sp verlander
rp valverde
rp fuentes
p percival
p devine
p lilly
b floyd, jered weaver, c.young

[REBEL5 AC]

No, by the look of your team you have first place already

[Dodgerbluesc]

This seems like a trade just to trade. Essentially you are trading an OF/DH-1B/SP for an OF/DH-1B/SP. And though I personally like Wainwright, you would be the one taking a downgrade in 2 of 3 positions, even though you will be getting the best player in the deal. In this case the best player of the deal isn't much better than the rest - it's not like your'e getting a 1st round talent.

Help me? viewtopic.php?t=373637

[WyldStallyn]

the other owner a sox fan?

a fairly even deal. could go either way

[wtu]

No reason to do it right now unless you are a huge Morneau fan, pretty much a lateral trade

mine viewtopic.php?f=26&t=373748