Brandon Phillips for Rickie weeks and Dioner Navarro - WHIR

[Amazinz]

Another NO vote. This is a really uneven trade.

[GunSlinger51]

I already said no but this trade is just smoking crack crazy.

[Captain Furtah]

I think you should do it...then trade Reyes for JJ Hardy, he is due for a big year!

[Padres Fan]

I think you should do it...then trade Reyes for JJ Hardy, he is due for a big year!

lmfao, while you are at it Sheets should get the CY this year

[lastingsgriller]

rickie weeks is so bad... i've gone on this rant before, so I won't bother to do it again.. but the main point of the rant is Rickie Weeks is very bad

[Captain Furtah]

Rickies ceiling and Phillips worst possible year (barring injury) MIGHT be close, throw in a catcher who is a boarderline starter in most leagues and you've got yourself a deal...

[dmendro]

that's where I was leaning guys, just wanted a sanity check. Thanks for all the responses.

[Padres Fan]

No problem good luck this season