Maholm or Jordan Zimmerman? WHIR

[dmendro]

Zimmerman. Stay away from Pirates pitching. The nats have improved. The Pirates have not.


PHIR
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=373693

[saemick]

thanks for all the help thus far. Below is my Pitching staff:

SP: Hamels, Haren, Verlander, Harang, Meche, Maholm/Zimmerman

let me know if that makes any difference

[TheBambino]

Should Maholm be taken in a 10 team mixed leauge? Each team takes 6 pitchers

[saemick]

Should Maholm be taken in a 10 team mixed leauge? Each team takes 6 pitchers

this is a 12 team mixed league

[Padres Fan]

thanks for all the help thus far. Below is my Pitching staff:

SP: Hamels, Haren, Verlander, Harang, Meche, Maholm/Zimmerman

let me know if that makes any difference

I think Maholm looks better in that Line Up, especially with Harang and Verlander, but pitching prospects no matter how they do in spring tend to disappoint me

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=373504

[michaelyoung4prez]

Malholm and run

[J35J]

Honestly, I don't know much about Maholm. I know the Pirates are awful though. Zimmerman is supposed to be a beast. I've heard a lot of good things about this kid. I think I'd go with him just strictly based on the hype and High ceiling.

Ok, now that I've actually looked at Maholm, I can say he is pretty good. Dude had 19 quality starts last year. Impressive along with a decent ERA and k/9. GO with Maholm.

This post made me laugh!!


With that said I would take the upside(though its not as high as some people think) with Zimmermann here...Maholm has little to no upside and you can get his production off of waivers/fa most of the time.

[The Artful Dodger]

Honestly, I don't know much about Maholm. I know the Pirates are awful though. Zimmerman is supposed to be a beast. I've heard a lot of good things about this kid. I think I'd go with him just strictly based on the hype and High ceiling.

Ok, now that I've actually looked at Maholm, I can say he is pretty good. Dude had 19 quality starts last year. Impressive along with a decent ERA and k/9. GO with Maholm.

This post made me laugh!!


With that said I would take the upside(though its not as high as some people think) with Zimmermann here...Maholm has little to no upside and you can get his production off of waivers/fa most of the time.

What do you mean, Paul Maholm outproduced THE Carlos Zambrano last year.