C Davis and K Johnson for Alexei Ramirez and K Slowey? WHIR

[Prooks25]

12 team 5x5 Roto 1250 IP Limit - Keeper League

I was offered two trades for Chris Davis

Trade 1:
Chris Davis and Kelly Johnson for Alexei Ramirez and Kevin Slowey

Trade 2:
Chris Davis and Kelly Johnson for Alexei Ramirez and Andre Either

Should I do either trade? Thanks in advance.

C Brian McCann
1B Albert Pujlos
2B Jose Lopez
3B Aramis Ramirez
SS JJ Hardy
OF BJ Upton
OF Carlos Quentin
OF Nelson Cruz
UTL Ryan Howard
BN Kelly Johnson
BN Cameron Maybin
BN Felipe Lopez
BN Chris Davis
BN Chris Dickerson
BN Shin-Soo Choo

SP CC Sabathia
SP Brandon Webb
SP Dan Haren
SP Brett Myers
SP Gavin Floyd
RP Jonathan Papelbon
RP Jonathan Broxton
RP Chris Ray

[ayebatter]

I'd pass.

[dave knight]

No, neither is enough for Davis' potential. Johnson is underrated at 2B as well.

[joe112]

I agree Pass on those.

[SignGuy]

Same team from previous post right?

I'll say it again here, but Davis gives you very little this year. Unless an injury occurs he will be useful but in Alexei you are getting a guy that helps now. I dont know if you need the pitching necessarily but i do like Slowey and would fit your staff nicely. Ethier you could slot over Cruz. I dont trust him and i like Ethier this year as well

Really depends if you want to go for it all this year, i think some people get a little to caught up with upside in keeper leagues. Your team is strong regardless. Will Davis make your keeper list next season?

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=373415

[SignGuy]

No, neither is enough for Davis' potential. Johnson is underrated at 2B as well.

If you get stats from your bench, then sure lol. Idk even in my keeper leagues i play for the season at hand.

[dooho]

yeah i like trade 2. alexei helps you now, big upgrade over lopez. davis is nice, but can his value get much higher? people are expecting 30/100 right now. if he doesn't do that you won't get this offer later on. i could also see you standing pat, as its early and there is no need to shake things up. let your team play to see.

would you mind helping with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=373414

[HOOTIE]

Trade 2 easy. You don't have a spot for Davis anyways. Alexei beats KJ by a lot. Ethier is close, if not better then Davis.

[trevizzle]

give me option #2

viewtopic.php?t=373422

[Prooks25]

I appreciate the responses guys...looks like you're all pretty much split on if I should do this or not..