miggy for mccann/morneau? WHIR

[fierro33]

ive been offered this trade:

i give

miguel cabrera (1st base elig only)
mike napoli
matt capps (or carlos marmol)

i receive:

justin morneau
brian mccann
jair jurrgenns

10 team 5x5 H2H


C Napoli
1b Miguel Cabrera
2b Robinson Cano
3b Alex Rodriguez
ss Michael Young
of Carlos Beltran
of Carl Crawford
of Nate Mclouth
util Chris Davis

bench:

Cory hart
Lastings Miledge
Orlando Cabrera

SP

CC Sabathia
Yovani Gallardo
Kevin Slowey
Ted Lilly
Brandon Morrow

RP

Carlos Marmol
Matt Capps
Joel Hanrahan
Matt Lindstrom

i will be trying to pick up kevin gregg and/or florida closer if they clear waivers which they prob should...

[Padres Fan]

I wouyldnt even though McCann looks better than Napoli, one you give up good HR's and BA with Cabrera that you need with AROD health issues and Davis not being established yet, plus Capps is the only established closer you have.


help with mine, please?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=373330

[fierro33]

anyone else?

[GoldenHawk]

id take that deal if you can grab a closer off the wire. cabrera is better than morneau but mccann vs napoli is pretty significant and enough to prob encourage me to take the deal. Morneau and Cabrera will be close in runs, sbs and rbis and if morneau can return to 30+ hrs there might not be a huge difference there either.

[ayebatter]

Pass, keep MCab