McLouth or Milledge for Liriano?

[floyd1313]

I ended up with a ton of OF's in my 12-team H2H keeper league, but lost out on some key pitchers.

My outfield is Beltran, Bay, McLouth, Milledge, Nelson Cruz, and Adam Lind. My pitching staff is Lincecum, Oswalt, Volquez, Cain, and Volstad.

Would you try to trade the older, potentially more reliable McLouth for Liriano...or the younger, potential upside keeper Milledge for Liriano?

Thanks for your help and WHIR!

[Dodgerbluesc]

Another owner has agreed to these??? If you've got those options I'd do either.

I say Milledge for Liriano looks a little better for you, but you win in both instances. Kind of shocked that an owner in a keeper leauge has agreed to do either deal to be honest. Good job.