My Manny -for- Lincecum?

[Maris09]

If that's the case I'd keep Manny and trade Holliday and Greinke for M. Cab. But see if the other manager will give you a SP to even it out.

I'm actually trying to make both trades at the same time.

It would leave me with

C Mauer
1B Votto
2B Alexei
3B MCab
SS Peralta
CI Beltre
MI K.Greene
OF Braun
OF Rios
OF Etheir
OF Crisp
UT Lowell/Zimmerman
BN Open Spot

SP Lincecum
SP Billingsly
SP Wainwright
SP Carpenter
RP Soria
RP Francisco
P Lyon
P Corpas
P Kuo
BN Bedard
BN Slowey

[Maris09]

Getting MCab and TImmy is better than having Manny and Holliday in my opinion.

The real question is....

Is getting MCab and Timmy better than having Manny and Holliday and Greinke?

[Amazinz]

Yeah if you get Cabrera and Lincecum for Manny, Holliday, and Greinke that's a win IMHO. You probably lose on overall value but you're getting two elite performers for three very good ones with question marks.