F Lewis for Hanrahan OR Jenks ?? ..WHIR

[SpecialFNK]

im looking for another closer. i have Nathan and Hoffman, and Hoffman likely wont be ready to start the season. this other owner has 4 closers (Cordero, Jenks, Hanrahan, Percival). hes looking for steals, and i could offer Fred Lewis. is that good?

MY ROSTER
CA- B McCann
1B- L Berkman
2B- K Johnson
3B- K Kouzmanoff
SS- D Jeter
CI- D Lee
MI- F Lopez
OF- G Sizemore
OF- M Kemp
OF- C Young
OF- Ad Jones
UT- P Konerko
UT- F Lewis
BN- C Dickerson
BN- Dn Murphy
BN- C Headley
BN- K Morales

SP- D Haren
SP- J Shields
RP- J Nathan
RP- T Hoffman
P- C Young
P- J Vazquez
P- R Johnson
P- W Rodriguez
BN- J Guthrie
BN- H Kuroda

HIS ROSTER
CA- A Pierzynski
1B- J Loney
2B- R Cano
3B- D Wright
SS- E Renteria
CI- A LaRoche
MI- K Greene
OF- N Markakis
OF- C Granderson
OF- R Ludwick
OF- R Ibanez
UT- N Cruz
UT- P Burrell
BN- D DeJesus
BN- A Hill

SP- J Santana
SP- R Halladay
RP- F Cordero
RP- J Hanrahan
P- B Jenks
P- T Percival
P- F Hernandez
P- J Lannan
BN- P Maholm
BN- C Carpenter
BN- J Zimmerman
BN- K Escobar

i dont like Cordero or Percival, so im targeting Hanrahan or Jenks. i think i can get Hanrahan easier than Jenks.
i was thinking Fred Lewis. is he enough? i could also offer Adam Jones? i think Chris Young is too much. if he wants someone more than Lewis i would have to look at a package trade, which maybe might be what he would want anyway since he could be full in the OF? i could go for another HR/RBI player like Burrell/Ibanez. in that case maybe Lewis and CYoung(OF) for Hanrahan(or Jenks) and Burrell(or Ibanez) ?
or maybe i could just offer C Young(OF) for Jenks ?

leave a link, WHIR

[rupertoooo]

Sure Jenks is good for you but no way on earth would the owner of Jenks move him for Lewis. Hanrahan may be obtainable depending on the other owners needs, but I believe Hanrahan is more valuable than Lewis. Good Luck

[Rhinochasers]

I agree...I would not do that trade if I was him. Even though a couple of them are older all his OF's are equal or better then Lewis. I like A Jones better but I still don't think I would make that trade.

[rib217]

If you can get either for F. Lewis do it instantly. I doubt you get Jenks, and if you get Hanrahan i'd still be very happy.


mine: viewtopic.php?t=373174