Rollins for C.Jones

[colsod01]

I'm strong at ss position and a little weak at 3b. I offered Rollins for any top 3b and was offered Jones. I realize his injury situation ,but like his overall #s. Should i take the deal or wait for another offer?
This is a roto,8 team with standard stats(5x5)
My team
Batters
C: Ryan Doumit (C)
1B: Ryan Howard (1B)
2B: Brandon Phillips (2B)
3B: Russell Martin (C,3B)
SS: Jose Reyes (SS)
OF: Matt Kemp (OF), Shane Victorino (OF), Jacoby Ellsbury (OF)
Util: Jimmy Rollins (SS)
BN: Carlos Pena (1B), Miguel Tejada (SS), Andre Ethier (OF), Nelson Cruz (OF)

Pitchers
SP: Brandon Webb (SP), Ervin Santana (SP)
RP: Jonathan Broxton (RP), Brandon Morrow (SP,RP)
P: Felix Hernandez (SP), Matt Cain (SP), Trevor Hoffman (RP)
BN: Chris Young (SP)

His team
Batters
C: Joe Mauer (C)
1B: Chris Davis (1B,3B)
2B: Chone Figgins (2B,3B)
3B: Chipper Jones (3B)
SS: Jhonny Peralta (SS)
OF: Adam Dunn (1B,OF), Matt Holliday (OF), Alex Rios (OF)
Util: Nate McLouth (OF)
BN: Aubrey Huff (1B,3B), Ivan Rodriguez (C), Willy Taveras (OF), Magglio Ordonez (OF)

Pitchers
SP: Cole Hamels (SP), Tim Lincecum (SP)
RP: Francisco Rodriguez (RP), Joakim Soria (RP)
P: Francisco Liriano (SP), Justin Verlander (SP), Ricky Nolasco (SP)
BN: Gavin Floyd (SP)

[converge241]

I wouldnt do this. May be odd playing a top C at 3B and all but either ride it out with him OR trade Martin to a team that needs a true Catcher for a 3B. I think you would be fine with Doumit. I would say trade Doumit but many people dont realize he was actually a top fantasy catcher last year and might not pay much as he doesnt have the same cache as a Martin.

[MadDog36]

You could use the OF upgrade. Ask for one of his good OF he has plenty to spare, if your going to trade Rollins. I'd package up 3 of your guys for Chris Davis, Stud OF (maybe holliday?)

Davis represents more value to your team, he could move Dunn ot 1b and not even blink.

[Gatorsfan]

No way do I deal a 1st round pick(Rollins) for Chipper "always dinged up" Jones. The other guy better bring a lot better to the table to get the 3rd best SS in fantasy

[Ernie.Whitt.]

No way do I deal a 1st round pick(Rollins) for Chipper "always dinged up" Jones. The other guy better bring a lot better to the table to get the 3rd best SS in fantasy

Yeah, no way. there will be opportunities during the year to make a move if nothing makes sense now. Your team is fine to start and you shouldnt make a bad move to solve a small problem.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=372971&p=2992559#p2992559

[colsod01]

Thanks for all the help. How bout Rollins for one of his sp? ie:Lincecum or Hamels. I don't need 3 ss