potential BIG TRADE

[MetsFan2009]

Would you guys do this trade? I trade Gil Meche and Carlos Lee and in return I get back Cameron and Lincecum. My other OF:
Jason Bay
Ryan Ludwick
Brad Hawpe
Curtis Granderson
and reserve is Adam Lind.
Rest of lineup:

C McCann
1B youkilis
2B Uggla
3b Aramis Ramirez
SS Mike young
1b/3b Sandoval (Giants)
2b/ss Alexi Ramirez (twins)Its Rotesseire (14 player keeper league) and Lee costs $3 out of a $26 payroll..... Lince costs .50 Meche .40 and Cameron .50

I feel as though if I make this trade I am going to suffer in the HR RBI and Avg Department. Cameron is projected for .245 25HR 75 RBI maybe 18-20 steals.Lee is projected for .309 34 HR and 122 RBI !! Quite a difference!

Other starts I have and why I think I need this trade.....

Liriano
Dempster
Nolasco
Maholm
Wellemeyer
Arroyo
Moyer
Sonnanstine
Dave Bush

[BillyHallDisciple]

I say go for it! You're getting the best pitcher in baseball, hands down + the price is right. Carlos Lee is awesome, but it looks like you can absorb losing him with all of the other outfielders you have.

Was this offered to you or are you thinking of offering it?

[Halo Homers]

Do the trade.

I'm personally not high on trading a top hitter for pitcher,but in this case your gettng a young stud SP for a aging OF who as hurt at the end of the year.

Hopefully all the innings LInceum pitched last year dont' become an issue. Be prepared to have LIncecum shutdown in September if the Giants are not contending.

Please help with mine. viewtopic.php?t=372900

[MetsFan2009]

Thanks for your help! Any other comments,opinions etc?