counter this trade? whir

[dubstar]

10 team h2h: avg., hr, rbi, r, sb, xbh
era, w, sv, k, whip, qs

C Sandoval
1B Fielder
2B Aviles
3B Wright
SS Drew
OF Manny, Kemp, Bruce
UTIL Dunn
BN Wieters, JD Drew, F Lopez

SP Webb, Shields, Gallardo, Grienke, Dempster, Harang, Kershaw

RP Wood, Bell

he offers me o hudson and burrell for dunn.

his team is:


Brian McCann
Derrek Lee
Orlando Hudson
Melvin Mora
Jimmy Rollins
Curtis Granderson
Jermaine Dye
Nelson Cruz
Pat Burrell
Jeff Francoeur
Jorge Posada

Dan Haren
Edinson Vólquez
Mariano Rivera
Joe Nathan
Ricky Nolasco
Brian Wilson
Gavin Floyd
Josh Johnson
Chris Young
Chris Volstad

wouldnt mind getting volquez off of him, but is it beneficial to my team? would offer dempster maybe in the trade.

dunn/dempster for his volquez/dye or burrell??

[B-Chad]

I like either offer a lot for you. I'm not a huge Dunn guy in Washington, in fact I like Dye more, and think Burrell can post similar numbers to Dunn as well. I hate Dempster, and though I have concerns about Volquez as well, I would take him 10 times out of 10 to Dempster. I'd give it a shot, the more likely to get done deal is Dunn/Dempster for Volquez/Burrell, but if you want to give it a shot, try Dunn/Dempster for Volquez/Dye. Help with mine please?

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=372883

[PopcornScrimp]

Sorry.

I'd try Dunn and Shields for his Granderson, Wilson and Volquez.
You could use some speed, and Grandy will provide SOME of the power you'd be giving up. You also could use another closer. Wilson might be a bit shaky but the fact that SF has such good pitching means a lot of low scoring close games for him to come in and nail down. He'd be a nice upgrade to your RP core. I think he'll be alittle better this year and finish 2-4 3.15 35 saves type of line. You could use it. Bell has never closed before and has a lot of mileage on his arm.

[dubstar]

yea the dye offer was shot down.

im trying to decide if offering for volquez/burrell or volquez/granerson would be better for my team. i cant decide, one minute i think granderson for the speed. but im hopiung to use maybin for that a little. then i think burrell will replace more of the power lost by dunn.


which do you think?

[kidsilk]

I like Volquez/Granderson better for your team but I think VOlquez/Burrell is more likely to be accepted. I would do either one though.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=372958