I have the 5th pick in a 12 team league with the following categories:
I believe from what I have been told by other GM's in the league that the first four picks will go like this:
So in a league that includes OBP and SLG would you take Reyes at number 5? I am leaning toward Miggy Cabrera but position scarcity is making me think twice about Reyes and Utley.
That early in the 1st round, I don't want to focus too much on positions but rather best player available. At the same time, Utley at 5 can thrive in a league with settings like ours (power). Reyes not so much but SS is so weak and Reyes is still a big Run and SP producer with these league settings.