Not knowing either teams needs, in a vacuum...which side is more appetizing? Braun's clearly the best player in this deal...does that mean that that side is the automatic winner?
It's hard and definitely one you definitely need to know the team needs. Putz really is not going to help in leagues without holds. If holds are a stat I would say the Braun side. If not it is closer, but stillthe Braun side. You could get Crawford Aramis for Braun by himself.
Thats hard but i would say Crawford,Aramis and Broxton, I would miss getting Braun, but Chipper is injury prone and Putz will possible get 0 saves setting up K-Rod, but the Braun you could deal with Jones seasonal hamstring issues and drop Putz for a closer on waivers.