Trade help...Felix Hernandez and Cano for Utley

[redman77]

12 team h2h keeper league, we are keeping 8 after this season...I have Utley and have been offered F Her and Cano. Would you do it? The rest of my hitters
Ianetta
Fielder
Tulo
Beltre
Carlos Guillen
Holliday
Granderson
Pence
J .Upton
bn Adam Jones
bn Felipe Lopez
bn Kevin Kouzmanoff

and my starting pitchers
Peavy
Shields
Lilly
Garza
Meche
Wandy Rodriguez
Paul Maholm

[myroto83]

definately not, never give up the best player in the deal.

[Johnny Tuttle]

I wouldn't do this, mostly because with only 8 keepers, you're better off keeping elite players over adding depth.

I dislike the notion that you can't win by giving up the best player in a deal in a general sense, but here, with such a short keeper list, I wouldn't trade down.

[aravtrain21]

No way.

[redman77]

Thanks guys.