Drop Reyes, Utley, or Halladay

[IrishDrunk]

Someone in the league has to drop one of those three due to keeper restrictions (12 Team, 4 keeper per team, H2H League.)

He told another league-mate he was deciding to drop either Reyes or Utley.

Just curious who you all would choose to axe (I pick #2 in the draft - so, that's why I keep wondering about this nonstop!)

[C2ThaLo88]

I'd drop Halladay in second if I could keep Reyes and Utley instead.

[Greenie40]

Same here. Gotta keep the stud hitters over a stud pitcher cuz they are just worth more, period.

[WyldStallyn]

you drop the 4/5th round pitcher and keep the first round infielders. duh

[capitalh]

No doubt about it, drop Halladay. 1st round pick position players are way too valuable to do otherwise.

[IrishDrunk]

Ha! That's pretty much what I was thinking!

So, gimpy hip or not, you're saying I should jump on Utley if he's there at #2? (or a healthy Reyes!)

[Xezus]

If reyes is there i would take him over utley, but i wouldnt be worried about utley's hip. grab utley at #2 if reyes gets picked with #1