Last Keeper spot help

[Larsjam]

Im in a 10 team Keeper League 6x6(extra cats are OPS and L), where we keep 4 players each year. I won this league last year, so I got the snake pick in the first round. Who would you keep as the 4th spot? I am leaning towards Phillips, but I am having a tough time letting Aramis and Adrian go also.

So far, I have declared:
Hanley Ramirez
BJ Upton
Manny Ramirez

My remaining options:
Brandon Phillips
Aramis Ramirez
Adrian Gonzalez
Alex Rios

[C2ThaLo88]

Phillips for the lack of quality 2B. If you want Aramis too, drop Manny maybe?