Blockbuster Keeper Trade. Needs some opinions.

[davercomeau]

14 player keeper league. H2H. Categories: R RBI HR SB SO AVG OB% TB K ERA WHIP W S CG SH. Must start 5 starters. I have Guthrie Wellemeyer, Trevor Cahill, Brett Anderson, Harang, Sabathia, Lester, Volquez, Josh Johnson, and Gallardo. I am looking to tell a starter for another bat. I offered Sabathia for Kemp straight up and after 5 exchanges back and forth this is the trade offer that I just received. Sabathia is obviously even more valuable because of the complete game and the shutout stat.

I send:
Sabathia
Justin Upton
Jason Werth
Troy Tulowitzki

I get:
Kemp
Hunter Pence
Neftali Feliz
Rafael Furcal

Werth is expendable. He is just ridding the bench. He is an injury risk, but he did go 20/20 last year and is one of the few righties in a left-handed lineup. Kemp is obvious my desire. Would you make this trade?

[tribefan08]

NO.

CC, tulo, upton and werth, wayy too much....

IMO

[davercomeau]

Thanks a lot. I agree. I just wanted to hear some other opinions.