Joe Saunders vs Jeremy Guthrie

[Bozo]

I'm in an AL only 4x4 keeper league and have a chance to get Guthrie ($10) for Saunders ($16). I know neither one of them is a frontline starter but most comments I'm reading seem to think that they should put up the same kind of numbers this coming year (4.00 ERA with a 1.30 WHIP). I expect that Saunders will post a few more wins as he pitches for a better team in a weaker division. However, I will be going into this year's draft with a few other expensive keepers so I'm considering this deal since I save apprx $6 in the swap. Should I pull the trigger?

[ant1thehand]

I would go with J. Saunders. He is the better ,smarter pitcher. Plus his team gots his back. Angles are good.


What do you think of my post question regarding keepers?

[mister_jay_peg]

To me, it's a $3 difference in production for $6 less.

I take it.

I also think Guthrie could break out this year. Wins is the only cat I think Saunders would be better in.

[Seanyfever]

Guthrie is developing, but I'll take Saunders.

Lend a quick voice to me.
viewtopic.php?t=372301