Scherzer/Cahill Trade

[Appleowner]

Hey guys,

I have a trade I've been offered that raised my eyebrows. Let me know what you think.

Dynasty League, 12 teams, H2H, standard scoring for pitchers. My team is below and the trade offer as well. Thanks for the input. GO BRAVOS!!

I receive in the trade: Max Scherzer, P Arizona

I give up in the trade: Mariano Rivera, P NYY and Trevor Cahill, P Oakland


My team:

A.J. Pierzynski
M Montero (M)
K Youkilis
J Giambi (R)
C C. Carter (M)
I Kinsler
C Jones
A LaRoche (R)
B Inge (R)
J D. Fields (M)
D Jeter
J Bartlett (R)
K Fukudome
M Ordonez
M Ramirez
D Murphy (R)
J Mather (R)
A Lind (M)
B Jones (M)
J Thome
H Bell
J Peavy
J Saunders
J Santana
J Danks
M Rivera
P Hughes
B Bruney (R)
D Wheeler (R)
J Schmidt (R)
J Lewis (R)
J Tazawa (R)
K Davies (R)
M Gonzalez (R)
S Marcum (I)
T Buchholz (I)
T Hudson (I)
A Laffey (M)
A Thompson (M)
B Colon (M)
B Matusz (M)
C Balester (M)
C Wade (M)
F An. Garcia (M)
T Cahill (M)

[etraum]

I don't like it. You are giving up too much for a guy whose injury prone. Cahill is suppose to be awesome and is expected to be ready by 2010. I like Scherzer, but I don't like him that much to give him away for Mariano (35 saves) and a budding A's pitching star in Cahill.

I just don't see what you are gaining.
Good Luck

[Appleowner]

I know, I love Cahill, although unproven, he has great stuff and the A's love him.

Thanks for the feedback.

[Johnny Tuttle]

That's not worth it for you, now or later.

viewtopic.php?t=372101

[Appleowner]

Thanks Johnny.

[Seanyfever]

Play to win this year. It has not yet begun. This trade does not help you.

viewtopic.php?t=372299