Blockbuster Trade: Do it?

[dshmizil1026]

i get:
alex rodriguez
joey votto

i trade:
ian kinsler
ryan braun

my current 3b is zimmerman and need more pop because i got furcal and mauer and jay bruce and milledge all possibly in my starting lineup. should i do it? if not, what kind of proposal should i make to the other kid? for JUST kinsler and braun? heres HIS team:
c: russel martin
1b: votto berkman
2b: aviles cano
3b: arod wright
ss: alexei ramirez
OF: bay, upton, abreu, chris young, jayson werth

SP: Billingsley, lester, webb, danks, vazquez, nolasco, shields
RP: Broxton, Nathan


BY THE WAY: ITS A 8 TEAM H2H YAHOO LEAGUE STANDARD SCORING
THIS IS MY TEAM:
c: mauer
1b: prince, dlee
2b: kinsler
3b: zimmerman, glaus
ss: furcal, guzman
OF: milledge, bruce, victorino, soriano, pence
SP: CC, oswalt, edison volquez, garza, saunders, cyoung
RP: lidge, wood

i do have some good outfielders so i could spare braun, and my infield is particularly weak and my pitching is kinda also... COME UP WITH A TRADE THAT INVOLVES ME SENDING THE OTHER TEAM KINSLER AND BRAUN. any possibility will be considered. thanks

[WyldStallyn]

that is a terrible offer. youre giving up two top 15 guys for an injured slugger who will be out ~2 months and a mid tier first basemen.

him giving you wright and berkman would be fair, not arod and votto.

[happyturtle]

ya definitely dont do that trade. Why trade Kinsler when you have no backup option?

Kinslaer and Braun are your BEST 2 players, you need top talent in return if you trade them.

Some combo from Wright, AROD, Nathan, Berkman, Bay,. Upton.

Wright has to be involved, or maybe AROD, Berkman, and Bay/upton/nathan.

dont sell yourself short

[ant1thehand]

Even though A-Rod is A-Rod i have to say dont do it. Braun is a stud and Kinsler had a stud year last year and can repeat. I dont like this trade for you.



Some advice on my topic below regarding keepers would be great.

[TheGhost]

Just say no to the bad trade. Trust us now. Thank us later.

[nateb]

Absolutely now way should you take that.

JUST SAY NO!